LakeList assistant
Fishing spots, food, lodging, marinas, and rentals around Butternut Lake.
Start here
Fishing forecast
Weather-based planning built from the National Weather Service hourly forecast near this lake.
Checking wind, precipitation, and near-term weather windows.
Water temperature
Modeled surface-temperature estimate built from seasonal climate, lake depth, and live National Weather Service air temperatures near this lake.
Seasonal estimate. Checking current National Weather Service air temperatures…
Comfortable summer pattern. Bass and panfish are active; early and late hours beat the midday heat.
Estimates are modeled, not measured. Actual temperatures vary with depth, wind mixing, and recent weather — verify conditions before swimming, boating, or heading onto ice.
Wisconsin DNR water assessment
The DNR assessment indicates specific public-health advice for this waterbody. Review current official guidance before your trip or eating your catch.
Water is impaired due to one or more pollutants and associated quality impacts.
DNR water check
From Wisconsin DNR / Citizen Lake Monitoring readings at Butternut Lake - Deep Hole.
Somewhat hazy, algae-prone water — summer clarity of 3 ft ranks among the lowest of monitored Wisconsin lakes.
Based on July–August volunteer averages from 2024–2025; each value shows its own year.Nutrient-rich, greener water — more algae and plant growth, common in shallower lakes.
Clearer than 18% of 596 monitored Wisconsin lakes with current readings.
Elevated phosphorus supports strong plant/algae growth pressure.
July/August means; counts in parentheses show how many samples went into each average.
| Year | Secchi | Chlorophyll-a | Total phosphorus |
|---|---|---|---|
| 2025 | — | 27.0 µg/L (2) | 41.0 µg/L (1) |
| 2024 | 3.0 ft (2) | 30.5 µg/L (2) | — |
| 2023 | 4.5 ft (1) | 18.0 µg/L (2) | — |
| 2022 | 3.7 ft (3) | 21.0 µg/L (2) | — |
| 2021 | 4.0 ft (1) | 16.5 µg/L (2) | 29.0 µg/L (1) |
| 2020 | 3.3 ft (7) | 17.5 µg/L (2) | 36.0 µg/L (1) |
| 2019 | 3.7 ft (4) | — | — |
| 2018 | 2.8 ft (3) | — | — |
| 2017 | 2.8 ft (1) | — | — |
| 2016 | 3.1 ft (2) | 23.0 µg/L (2) | — |
Latest individual samples: Secchi 4.5 ft (2025-06-06), chlorophyll-a 6 µg/L (2026-06-07), and total phosphorus 41 µg/L (2025-07-21).
Secchi clarity is how deep a black-and-white disk stays visible from the surface — more feet means clearer water.
Chlorophyll-a is an algae pigment; higher values signal more algae in the water column.
Total phosphorus is a nutrient that feeds algae and aquatic plants. It is not a weed survey — depth, bottom type, water movement, and management change the actual lake experience.
Official Wisconsin information
LakeList links to the authoritative record so you can verify maps, rules, and current notices before leaving.
Historical depth maps are not for navigation. Verify regulations and access at the official source before your trip.
Historical Wisconsin DNR maps
2 converted map sheets. These historical surveys are not for navigation.
Navigable depth map
Pan, zoom, and inspect the converted Wisconsin DNR historical map image in the browser. Historical survey — not for navigation.

Source: Wisconsin DNR · WBIC 2283300 · image navigation only; spatial alignment pending · Historical lake maps are not for navigation.
Source: Wisconsin Department of Natural Resources. Converted for browser access with source URLs, checksums, and retrieval dates retained. Historical lake maps are not for navigation.
Fishbrain community activity
Aggregated public catch activity matched to Butternut Lake. Exact catch locations and angler details are not shown.
Catch analytics
Pick a species to see when anglers reported it, compare against all fish by month, then scan year-by-year catch volume.
No yearly catch aggregates yet.
Catch counts are community reports, not a population survey or a guarantee of current fishing conditions.
View source on FishbrainAccess
Nearby
Fishery
Wisconsin DNR stocking
The latest published year is 2025, when 1,999 fish were recorded across 1 entry.
Depth FAQ
Butternut Lake is 32 feet deep at its deepest point and averages about 14 feet, according to Wisconsin DNR records.
Yes. LakeList publishes a free interactive depth contour map of Butternut Lake at a typical 5-foot interval, with an optional 3D underwater view, derived from C-MAP Genesis community sonar (derived) survey data.
The interactive depth contours are derived from C-MAP Genesis community sonar (derived). Each contour set passes a visual QA review against the source document before it is published. The depths are derived from community sonar recordings (C-MAP Genesis Social Map, used with permission), with gaps between recordings interpolated; not for navigation.
Trust and freshness
Keep exploring